BlackHartBlackHart
Scores/Kinetiq/Provenance/Economic Soundness
D2

Economic Soundness

Robustness of economic model against flash loans, MEV, liquidation cascades, and incentive misalignment under stress.

Weight 13%72% confidence
53
Concerning
info

How This Score Is Built

Robustness of economic model against flash loans, MEV, liquidation cascades, and incentive misalignment under stress.

+23Strong positive
+12Positive
+5Slight positive
−15Strong negative
−8Negative
−3Slight negative

Scoring Tree

BRI Formula
300 + 700 × ∏(Dᵢ/100)^wᵢ
688
Current BRI
D2Economic Soundness
Weight 12%
53
(53/100)^0.1209 = 0.9261
Contributing Factors
+11CONFIRMED Critical (#2256, passing PoC): StakingAccountant._getExchangeRatio 'totalStaked + rewardsAmount - totalClaimed - slashingAmount' is unchecked subtraction — permanent underflow brick when slashing exceeds headroom; no admin function reduces totalSlashing. Verified in source. NOTE: live sanityChecker now bounds the slashing delta magnitude, raising the activation cost vs the original address(0) premise.
+11ON-CHAIN: live exchange ratio is healthy (1 kHYPE = ~1.0188 HYPE; kHYPE supply ~16.14M) — the underflow scenario has NOT triggered in production; it is a latent tail-risk, not a realized loss
+11Exchange-rate model is exchange-ratio (not rebasing); rate locked at queue time, socializes slashing onto in-queue holders (#1715/#38 — accepted Duplicate at High on Cantina)
+11Precision/dust: mulDiv truncation (#2584); 1e10 buffer-remainder dust leak (#2561); first-depositor/donation inflation surface (#2516)
+11Raised 50 -> 53: live sanityChecker bounds the dominant economic-attack magnitude; rate is healthy and behaving
Evidence Sources
blackhart_analysisMay 30sha256:1acaa6010260....View

Score Composition

+11

CONFIRMED Critical (#2256, passing PoC): StakingAccountant._getExchangeRatio 'totalStaked + rewardsAmount - totalClaimed - slashingAmount' is unchecked subtraction — permanent underflow brick when slashing exceeds headroom; no admin function reduces totalSlashing. Verified in source. NOTE: live sanityChecker now bounds the slashing delta magnitude, raising the activation cost vs the original address(0) premise.

Strong positiveopen_in_newDeFi Llama TVLMay 30, 2026
+11

ON-CHAIN: live exchange ratio is healthy (1 kHYPE = ~1.0188 HYPE; kHYPE supply ~16.14M) — the underflow scenario has NOT triggered in production; it is a latent tail-risk, not a realized loss

Strong positiveopen_in_newDeFi Llama TVLMay 30, 2026
+11

Exchange-rate model is exchange-ratio (not rebasing); rate locked at queue time, socializes slashing onto in-queue holders (#1715/#38 — accepted Duplicate at High on Cantina)

Strong positiveopen_in_newDeFi Llama TVLMay 30, 2026
+11

Precision/dust: mulDiv truncation (#2584); 1e10 buffer-remainder dust leak (#2561); first-depositor/donation inflation surface (#2516)

Strong positiveopen_in_newDeFi Llama TVLMay 30, 2026
+11

Raised 50 -> 53: live sanityChecker bounds the dominant economic-attack magnitude; rate is healthy and behaving

Strong positiveopen_in_newDeFi Llama TVLMay 30, 2026

Evidence Chain (1 files)

BlackHart AnalysisMay 30, 2026, 12:00 AM
open_in_newEconomic Soundness — DeFi Llama TVL
sha256:1acaa6010260...

Score History

No dimension-level score changes recorded yet.

Methodology: 2.1Formula: 1.1Weights: 1.1